The dice notebook
Dice Games for Two: Pig or Shut the Box?
Two accessible dice games for two people are Pig and Shut the Box. Choose Pig if you want repeated decisions about whether to risk another roll. Choose Shut the Box if you prefer choosing number combinations after a roll. Both use simple arithmetic, but their scoring goals and turn structures differ.

The comparison below uses the versions explained on this website. Physical sets and other apps may use different house rules, so agree on the details before starting.
Choose by the decision you enjoy
In Pig, your repeated question is “Roll again or hold?” Successful rolls add to the current turn total, and holding saves those points. A roll of one ends the turn and loses its unbanked points.
In Shut the Box, your question is “Which open numbers should I close?” The chosen tiles must add up to the roll. The round ends when no legal combination remains, or when you close every tile.
They focus on different choices: accepting risk in Pig and managing combinations in Shut the Box.
Check what you need at the table
For physical Pig, use one ordinary six-sided die and a sheet with separate columns for banked scores and the current turn. Start both players at zero. In the version here, the target is at least one hundred banked points.
For physical Shut the Box, use a numbered board and two ordinary dice. You can also mark numbered spaces on paper, provided closed numbers stay unavailable for that round. Both players should use the same board size and dice rule.
The two-player Shut the Box guide covers that game's setup. A list of games using two dice answers a different question about equipment.
Keep the scoring systems separate
Suppose you have twenty banked points in Pig and collect twelve during your turn. Holding raises your banked score to thirty-two. Rolling a one instead leaves your banked score at twenty; the twelve unbanked points disappear.
In sum-scoring Shut the Box, leaving tiles two, five, and eight open produces a final score of fifteen. A lower score is better. Closing every tile gives zero, which is the best possible round score under that system.
Write the scoring goal at the top of the sheet when switching games. Read the Pig rules before applying a rule remembered from another variant.
Illustrated worksheet

This diagram summarizes the example in this article.
Agree on turns and match length
In Pig, players alternate after a hold or a roll of one. On this website, reaching the target requires banking the points with Hold. Merely collecting enough during the turn does not finish the game.
In Shut the Box, let each player complete a fresh round, then compare the remaining sums. Give both players the agreed opportunity to play before deciding the round winner. Equal lowest scores can be a tie.
For a physical match, choose one round each or agree on several rounds beforehand. If you total scores across rounds, use the same rules throughout and record that match format clearly.
Try a pair of learning rounds
Play one practice round of each game before deciding which to continue. Ask each player to explain one choice: why they held in Pig, or why they selected a particular combination in Shut the Box.
For browser play, open the games and choose the appropriate friend-room option. Each player joins on their own device. Use the displayed rules and controls, then compare which kind of decision you would enjoy making again.
Rules scope: The Little Dice Club rules. Sources and calculation methods. Probability examples are not overall game win rates.